Close this search box.
Close this search box.

Final Cut Pro = iMovie Pro (IMHO)

Share This Post

Two months ago, I wrote about the Final Cut Pro X announcement and wondered aloud, is Final Cut Pro X really iMovie Pro? Well the answer would appear to be ‘Yes, this is a classic bait and switch.’
How do I draw this conclusion? Especially when the software was released only two days ago? Two very big reasons: when you first start up the program you are greeted with a big button that offers to import iMovie Events; and FCP-X cannot open any previous version of Final Cut. A lot of people on the web are saying “Whoa, calm down, this is just a 1.0 release, there are bound to be features missing,” to which I say “Are you high?”
This is not a 1.0 release, it is the 10th version of Final Cut Pro, a new release that although was rewritten from the ground up, it has no backward compatibility (except with iMovie). It is supposed to be a professional application, but it has added a lot of gimmicky effects (that can also be found in previous versions of iMovie), removed most of the important fine-grain controls (“easy to use”, like iMovie) and is trying to change the paradigm of video editing to match that of iMovie.
Here’s is a partial list of essential tasks required in a professional workflow that Final Cut Studio 3 did, but FCP-X can’t do:

  • Inter-operate with other applications via XML, OMF or AAF
  • Allow 64 bit color grading with primary and secondary passes,
  • Multi-track recording and mixing (although this was buggy and somewhat limited)
  • Match frame
  • Create my own project and media management setup
  • Edit without an internet connection

And I’m sure as I get further into this program, new and fresh outrages will apear. Apple should have called this what it is: iMovie Pro. It is a big step up for iMovie users, and I’m sure that the new features that are being ballyhooed are timesaving and great once you get used to using them. They say that there was not one line of Final Cut Pro 7 code that went into FCP-X. How much iMovie code is in there?
Apple is clearly aiming at the prosumer – the vlogger, the wedding shooter, the YouTube enthusiast – and that’s great. But the only people using FCP were professional and semi-professional editors (I say this based on nothing other than common sense and pure conjecture – who else would be willing to put down $1,000 just to edit their home movies?), and to market this as a new version of Final Cut Pro is dishonest.
Maybe they will rectify these omissions. I will wait and see, but until then I’ll be using the Final Cut Suite. And if they don’t, and I’m forced by circumstance to make a choice…I wonder if Avid is going to offer crossgrading pricing on Media Composer again anytime soon?

More To Explore

Current360 2024 Predictions crystal ball

2024 Predictions

Thanks to everyone who responded to our 2024 Predictions survey last month. While the sample size wasn’t quite the size of a Pew or Nielsen,

Tradition and digital media crown become digital

The King is dead.
Long Live the King.

No we’re not talking about Charles VII or his father Charles VI. Instead, we’re recognizing the passing of the baton after years of shifts from

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

I am not a robot
Ed Sharp Current360 headshot

Ed Sharp

Ed brings 15 years of traditional and digital media sales experience to the agency, giving us a perspective most agencies don’t have. When he’s not working or seeking new knowledge, Ed hangs out with his wife, two kids, two dogs, one cat, and a hamster. And yes, the cat and hamster are best friends.

Chaney Given

Chaney is a talented and accomplished designer and illustrator, who has expanded his skill set to include motion graphics and video editing. With nearly a decade of experience, his client work includes Waterstep, Baptist Health, the Archdiocese of Louisville Catholic Schools, First Harrison Bank, and many more