The Pricebo Effect: Considering the Power of the Price Point in Shaping Consumer Beliefs

Share This Post

Most folks would agree that it’s natural/logical to believe that more expensive products are superior to their lesser expensive counterparts. I’m certainly guilty of it. After all, if a product costs more, it must be because it’s made better, will last longer — or in the case of wine — because it tastes better, right?
Not so fast.
In 2008, a study was conducted by the California Institute of Technology and Stanford University to determine how consumers evaluate expensive wines versus cheaper wines.
The study required student volunteers to taste wine samples, which were identified by different price points of $10, $35, $45 and $90 per bottle. The wines were divided into pairs ($10 vs $90 and $35 vs $45 per bottle), and the subjects were asked to compare and grade each. As the subjects tried the wines, their brains were scanned using an MRI machine, which measured activity in their frontal cortexes, or pleasure centers.
When the subjects were told the prices of the wines before tasting, they reliably graded pricier wines more favorably than cheaper ones. Interestingly, the MRI readings also revealed more brain activity in the subjects’ pleasure centers as they sampled the more expensive selections.
But here’s the twist: The samples were actually the same wine.
The subjects were brought back eight weeks later to taste the wines again — this time without price cues. And sure enough, with no price information on which to base their beliefs, the subjects showed no definitive preference for any of the wines.
The wine study clearly illustrates the power that price points have on influencing consumer beliefs. (Similar arguments have been made about product packaging and other superficial factors.) Nevertheless, the study reveals an interesting phenomenon that raises the question: Why don’t all brands just inflate their prices to enhance the perceived quality of their products?
Because it’s not that simple.
Effectively wielding the Pricebo Effect, as I’ve cornily coined it, is tricky: McDonald’s can’t get away with selling $15 hamburgers; Wal-Mart can’t get away with selling $10,000 earrings; and if Miller High Life cost $8 a bottle, I wouldn’t be downing a 12-pack each night. (Conversely, boutique brands like Mercedes-Benz can’t sell $15,000 sedans, and Rolex can’t hawk $50 watches.)
The bottom line? Higher price points have the power to increase consumers’ perceptions about product quality, but ONLY if it’s right for the product and right for the brand.
The MRI wine study provides some captivating insights into how consumers equate price with quality — even at the brain-chemistry level. And it proves that brands can strategically use higher price points to increase consumer favorability — but only if the price is right.
So what gives? Does this ring true for you? Have you ever been seduced by a high price point? Do tell.

More To Explore

Outdoor Advertising Current360 Hero Image

Advertising in the Great Outdoors.

In the 1920s, a company called Burma Shave — producers of brushless shaving cream — started putting signs up that delighted and educated drivers. These

Paul Rand Current360 Hero Image

Who Influenced the Influencers?

In advertising, pretty much everyone has been influenced by someone else. As we’ve been bringing you stories about ad legends like Bill Bernbach and George

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Chaney Given

Chaney is a talented and accomplished designer and illustrator, who has expanded his skill set to include motion graphics and video editing. With nearly a decade of experience, his client work includes Waterstep, Baptist Health, the Archdiocese of Louisville Catholic Schools, First Harrison Bank, and many more